ESCRS - Finding an AMD Holy Grail ;
ESCRS - Finding an AMD Holy Grail ;

Finding an AMD Holy Grail

Ongoing European study searches for intermediate AMD markers.

Finding an AMD Holy Grail
Gearoid Tuohy
Published: Wednesday, February 1, 2023

By Dr Gearóid Tuohy

With 700 patients enrolled and well underway, the European MACUSTAR project aims to develop novel clinical endpoints for those with intermediate age-related macular degeneration (iAMD).

There is a significant unmet need for treatment options in both early and intermediate AMD. While there are some valuable treatments for late-stage non-neovascular AMD (i.e., geographic atrophy)—using particular agents to slow the progression of the disease—the “holy grail” for a therapy in the ophthalmic community is a process to intervene earlier in the pathology, preventing the later stages of the disease and, thus, minimising visual loss.

The MACUSTAR project will characterise the functional deficits in iAMD and develop and validate functional, structural, and patient-reported outcome measures. Additional goals include investigating risk factors for progression from iAMD to late AMD, according to Frank Holz MD.

As there may be no universally accepted clinical endpoints for early or intermediate stages of the disease, Professor Holz commented that accomplishing this goal might be challenging. Designing, using, and measuring the “right endpoints,” therefore, will be imperative for MACUSTAR.

“Measuring a patient with intermediate AMD with BCVA would not be helpful, as it may maintain for a long period until it crashes into late-stage disease development,” he explained. “So we need other endpoints accepted by the regulatory authorities to test interventions in these earlier stages.”

MACUSTAR investigators across Europe are assessing methods for structural, functional, and patient-reported outcome tests; reliable test/retest processes; and how the community can differentiate between different neighbouring disease states and how these may change over time.

The project covers this gap in the research work to develop key outcomes supported by expert academic, clinical, and commercial organisations. MACUSTAR will follow more than 700 AMD patients over three years, using state-of-theart imaging techniques, vision testing, and patient-reported outcome measures that capture the disease’s impact on quality of life.

The continent-wide project has 20 clinical sites to date. Each site collects data including mean and point-wise retinal sensitivities on scotopic/mesopic fundus-controlled perimetry, low-luminance visual acuity (LLVA), low luminance deficit, Moorfields Acuity Chart visual acuity, dark adaptation absolute threshold and rod intercept time, and several more assays. Sites also collect patient-reported low-luminance functioning.

One of MACUSTAR’s valuable research outcomes so far is further validation of the “Vision Impairment in Low Luminance (VILL) questionnaire”, which captures visual functioning and vision-related quality of life (VRQoL) under low luminance, low-contrast conditions relevant to AMD.

The relevance of this work only increases as other existing patient-reported outcome instruments do not fulfil regulator development requirements or sufficiently capture AMD patients’ difficulties. The new VILL questionnaire now supports the psychometric performance of patients, including internal consistency, item fit, subscale structure, test/retest reliability, and construct validity in a multinational, multilanguage setting. Prof Holz noted this research could impact clinical research, practice, and policy in the future.

The Innovative Medicines Initiative (IMI), with support from the European Commission and the European Federation of Pharmaceutical Industries and Associations (EFPIA), funds the €16.2M project—scheduled to complete in spring 2024 after running for approximately 6.5 years.

For more information on MACUSTAR, please visit

Prof Holz spoke at the 22nd EURETINA Congress in Hamburg.

Frank G Holz MD is Chair of the Department of Ophthalmology at University Hospital Bonn, Germany.

Colour fundus photograph and optical coherence tomography of intermediate AMD with subretinal pigment epithelial drusen
Tags: AMD
Latest Articles
Supplement: The Future of Refractive Surgery - Lenticule Extraction, Phakic IOLs and Beyond


Harold Ridley’s Brilliant Innovation

A transformative surgery that continues to save the vision of millions every year.


ESCRS Welcomes New President

An interview with incoming president Filomena Ribeiro.


What is the Best Option for Hyperopia?

Two renowned surgeons engaged in a thought-provoking debate in Vienna.


Updating the Hippocratic Ideal

Cataract surgery can become more sustainable.


Webinar Examines Impact of Investors on Ophthalmology


Gazing into a Lenticule-Based Future

New and emerging platforms and applications predicted to drive growth for lenticule-based refractive surgery.


It’s in the Bag

ESCRS Heritage Lecture explores the enigma of the anterior hyaloid.


MDR Requirements Affect All Ophthalmic Surgeons

Ophthalmology needs to come to grips with medical devices under new EU regulations.


SIDICS for a More Sustainable OR

Reducing the environmental burden of cataract surgery worldwide.