ESCRS - SMILE for Hyperopia and Hyperopic Astigmatism ;
ESCRS - SMILE for Hyperopia and Hyperopic Astigmatism ;

SMILE for Hyperopia and Hyperopic Astigmatism

Positive results in study indicate current technique overcomes past challenges. Cheryl Guttman Krader reports.

SMILE for Hyperopia and Hyperopic Astigmatism
Cheryl Guttman Krader
Cheryl Guttman Krader
Published: Thursday, December 1, 2022

Results from a 12-month multicentre study investigating SMILE for spherocylindrical hyperopia suggest it is a safe, effective, and predictable procedure that appears to be associated with marginally better refractive results and less regression compared to hyperopic Femto-LASIK.

“We have been working on SMILE for hyperopia since 2010, and now, in my opinion, it is one of the biggest breakthroughs in laser refractive surgery since SMILE was introduced,” said Dr Walter Sekundo MD, PhD.

“We need a faster laser for the procedure. As performed with the VisuMax femtosecond laser in this study, the treatment takes 32 seconds. Once approved, however, the treatment will be done with the new VisuMax 800 laser, and then it will only take about 12 seconds.”

The multicentre study was conducted to obtain CE approval for the procedure. It involved eight centres in Europe, China, and India and included 374 eyes of 199 patients. The procedure used a 6.3 mm optical zone, 2.0 mm transition zone, and lenticule thickness of 25 μm centrally and 10 μm at the edge. Mean attempted hyperopic sphere was +2.76 D (maximum +6.00 D), mean attempted refractive cylinder was +0.88 D (maximum +4.75 D), and mean attempted spherical equivalent refraction (SEQ) was +3.20 (maximum +6.50 D).

Safety results showed the safety index was low on postoperative day one but steadily increased to about 1.0 at month 12. No eyes lost more than two lines of BCVA, 1.2% of eyes lost two lines, 11% lost one line, and 10% gained one line. Loss of contrast sensitivity was seen only at 12 and 18 cycles per degree.

Visual acuity outcomes analysed for the subgroup of 219 eyes treated with a plano target showed 68% achieved 20/20 UCVA at 12 months, and 88% saw 20/25 uncorrected.

“Remember that these hyperopes are often older patients who already have some degree of presbyopia. Two-thirds of my patients were treated with mini-monovision,” Dr Sekundo said.

Refractive results showed good predictability. At 12 months, SEQ was within 0.5 D of attempted in 81% of eyes and ±1.0 D in 93%.

“I think it is important to note the undercorrection was predominantly in eyes treated for greater than +3.0 D SEQ, and the only adjustment to the nomogram was from an earlier study of hyperopic femtosecond lenticule extraction. There is room for improvement in the accuracy of the procedure, but I think it can be achieved with further nomogram adjustments,” Dr Sekundo said, adding astigmatism correction was also very satisfactory.

He described the refractive stability as excellent, although he noted a change in SEQ of 0.07 D between 9 and 12 months.

“It is necessary to overcorrect initially when treating for hyperopia because epithelial healing leads to some regression. Most studies follow patients for only 9 months. In our study, there was very little change in refraction beyond 9 months, but we need to look further to see if it is related to late epithelial healing or presbyopia progression,” Dr Sekundo said.

He acknowledged visual recovery after SMILE was slower than Femto-LASIK for hyperopia and hyperopic astigmatism. However, he said it is a trade-off worth taking, considering SMILE seemed to have an advantage of less regression and less postoperative neurotrophic keratopathy/dry eye symptoms.

Dr Sekundo also reported the procedure was associated with a higher incidence of visible haze compared to myopic SMILE.

“The haze was transient, but it is an issue that is being looked at more closely,” he said.

Dr Sekundo presented at the 40th Congress of the ESCRS in Milan.

Walter Sekundo MD, PhD, Professor and Chairman, Department of Ophthalmology, Phillips University of Marburg, Germany.

Tags: SMILE, Astigmatism
Latest Articles
Supplement: ESCRS Clinical Trends Survey 2022 Results


Supplement: Premium IOL Solutions - Your way out of the Labyrinth


An Open-Eyed View of AI

Reaping the benefits will require good data and careful design and oversight.


ESCRS Supports Cataract Project in Nepal

Partnership with Ridley Eye Foundation delivers care in remote mountainous areas.


Emerging Ophthalmic AI Applications


Links in Eye Care Delivery and Climate Change

Exploring the relationship shows strategies are needed for both mitigation and adaptation.


Femto-LASIK Sets High Bar for Myopic Correction

Debate continues over relative merits of femto-LASIK and SMILE.


The Symphony of AI in Ophthalmology

Henahan Prize Finalist Essay


ESCRS Launches Leadership and Business Innovation Weekends

Frankfurt programme will feature interactive education on leadership and finance.


Striving for Perfection in LASIK

Combining topography and astigmatism data helps achieve 20/15 in most eyes.